Skip to content
EU Parl Watch

Changes between two versions

What changed between the resolution motion and the adopted text

From · resolution motion· 9 Dec 2020

B-9-2020-0401

on the implementation of the EU water legislation

To · adopted text· 17 Dec 2020

TA-9-2020-0377

Implementation of the EU water legislation

Changes to the text itself, in document order. Cover page, citations and punctuation-only edits are left out; they are under “Every difference”.

The changes · 9

Change 1

Changed:V. whereas hydropower has hugethe potential to decarbonise electricity generation to a certain extent and iscan therefore contributingcontribute to reaching the EU’s climate and energy targets under the Paris Agreement; whereas hydropower needs to be seen in a holistic manner, including its effects on hydromorphological conditions and habitats; whereas, compared to wind power and solar-generated electricity, hydropower is less volatile and therefore helps to keep the power supply constant and the grid stable; whereas pumped hydro storage accounts for more than 90 % of the EU’s energy storage capacity; whereas the European Union should engagesupport Member States engaging in environmentally friendly hydraulichydropower projects, that at the same time do not pose threats to the health of local communities;

Change 2

Changed:Z. whereas one million people in Europe have no access to water and eight million have no sanitation, whereas globally 844 million people do not have safe access to safe drinking water, and whereas a third of the world’s population lacks basic sanitation; whereas the European Citizen’s Initiative (ECI) Right2Water collected over 1.81,8 million signatures in March 2014; whereas Right2Water asked for the liberalisation of water services to be brought to an end, guaranteeing water and sanitation for all in the EU and globally, better access to drinking water for the public and more transparency on the quality of water, as well as enshrining the right to water in EU legislation; whereas the Commission has adopted its communication in response to the ‘Right2Water initiative’; whereas in its resolution of 8 September 2015 on the follow-up to the European Citizens’ Initiative Right2Water, Parliament criticised the Commission for failing to meet the initiative’s demands and called on the Commission to recognise universal access and human right to water;

Change 3

Added:2. Rejects any attempt to treat water as a commodity (as with the trading of water futures on the New York Stock Exchange); deplores the implications of the commodification of nature, with essential public goods opened up for speculation, denying the universal right to their use;

Change 4

Changed:28.29. Insists that, when assessing the environmental impact of hydropower installations, a holistic approach is needed, including the societal benefits of providing emission-free electricity and the contribution of hydropower and pumped hydro storage to securing the energy supply;supply, and adverse effects on surface waters and habitats; underlines in this respect the striking contribution ofthat electricity generated by hydropower plants can make to reaching the EU’s climate and energy targets and the EU’s commitments under the Paris Agreement;Agreement, but considers that this should not be achieved to the detriment of surface waters and the protection of habitats; acknowledges that there are ways and technologies to lower the impact on the environment and aquatic wildlife; points out that there is great potential to increase the efficiency of existing river power plants;

5 more changes

Change 5

Changed:33.34. Notes that one area in which the WFD was viewed by stakeholders as ineffective is managing the effects of droughts; calls on the Member States to devote more efforts to addressing climate change and the new (over-) abstraction problems that might arise in river basins, including those not historically facing abstraction challenges1a;challenges; notes that a holistic approach to water management and climate adaptation could make responses more efficient and reduce the impact of extreme events; calls for the full integration of climate change considerations into the implementation of the directive and also highlights the potential of nature-based solutions in this regard; reiterates that sufficient public spending should be ensured for the objectives of the WFD and the required adaptations;

Change 6

Changed:36.37. Welcomes the targets for reducing the use and risks of pesticides by 50 % by 2030 and for reducing the loss of nutrients from fertilisers, as established in the Farm to Fork and Biodiversity Strategies, the decision to revise the Directive on the sustainable use of pesticides and the inclusion of improved nutrient management in the objectives of the new CAP strategic plans and of the two strategies; calls for the translation into legislation of the above-mentioned targets and objectives, as well as the upcoming zero-pollution action plan; highlights the urgent need to reduce the impact of pesticides on drinking water resources by fully addressing their protection in the (re-) approval of active substances and the (re-) authorisation(re-)authorisation of pesticides;

Change 7

Changed:37.38. Calls on the Commission to revise the quality standards of the Groundwater Directive, improve the homogenisation of standards and reduce the wide range of thresholds within MembersMember States;States in the Groundwater Directive;

Change 8

Added:39. Calls on the Commission and the Member States to enhance the synergies between water and biodiversity policies by introducing appropriate measures to better protect small water bodies and groundwater ecosystems in the context of river basin management, including reporting requirements, guidance and projects;

Change 9

Changed:50.52. Welcomes the fact that the EU responded partially to Right2Water in the recast of Council Directive 98/83/EC on the quality of water intended forDrinking humanWater consumptionDirective by inserting a new article on access to water and more transparency on its quality to improve health and the environment; calls on the Member States to fully implement and enforce the WFD in order to ensure access to water for all and fully respond to Right2Water;