What changed between the resolution motion and the resolution motion joint

Changed:B. whereas the tobacco epidemic is one of the biggest public health threats the world has ever faced, killing more than 8 million people a year around the world; whereas every year, the tobacco industry costs the world 600 million trees, 200 000 hectares of land, 22 billion tonnes of water and 84 million tonnes of CO2;

Changed:E. whereas new and emerging products that emit aerosols contain dangerous chemical substances that createsuch aerosolsas withformaldehyde, toxicacetaldehyde and carcinogenicacrolein residues,that suchare asknown formaldehyde,to acetaldehydehave toxic and acrolein;carcinogenic properties;

Removed:H. whereas Europe’s Beating Cancer Plan sets the goal of creating a ‘tobacco-free generation’ by 2040, where less than 5 % of the population uses tobacco compared to 24 % today; whereas expanding smoke-free environments is an important policy tool that has already contributed to improvements in rates of both mortality and morbidity, including by motivating smokers to quit and discouraging people from taking up smoking;

Added:H. whereas third-hand smoke pollutants that cling to furniture and other surfaces are dangerous, especially for children;

Added:I. whereas the goal of Europe’s Beating Cancer Plan is to create a ‘tobacco-free generation’ by 2040, where less than 5 % of the population uses tobacco, as compared with 24 % today; whereas expanding smoke-free environments is an important policy tool that has already contributed to improvements in rates of both mortality and morbidity, including by motivating smokers to quit and by discouraging people from taking up smoking;

Added:J. whereas among adult respondents to the 2023 Eurobarometer survey on the attitudes of Europeans towards tobacco and related products, 3 % are current users of e-cigarettes and 4 % are current users of HTPs, compared to 2 % in 2020;

Removed:J. whereas the current Council Recommendation of 30 November 2009 on smoke-free environments sets out recommendations for Member States to implement the WHO FCTC and thus provides guidance for them to comply with their legal commitments to protect people from second-hand smoke in all indoor workplaces, public transport and indoor public spaces;

Added:L. whereas according to the Eurobarometer survey, 54 % of current and past smokers started smoking before the age of 19 and 14 % started before the age of 15;

Removed:K. whereas all EU Member States are parties to the WHO FCTC; whereas Principle 1 of the guidelines for the implementation of Article 8 stipulates that the total elimination of smoking and tobacco smoke in specific spaces or environments is required to protect against exposure and create a 100 % smoke-free environment;

Added:M. whereas the Eurobarometer data indicate that 74 % of respondents have experienced people smoking in outdoor terraces and 71 % of respondents have experienced people using e-cigarettes and HTPs in the same places; whereas the survey also indicates that there is public support for banning smoking in outdoor spaces where social distancing cannot be ensured, including parks, beaches and entrances to public buildings;

Removed:L. whereas the Conference of the Parties (COP) to the WHO FCTC recognises HTPs as tobacco products, which are subject to the provisions of the WHO FCTC, as noted in Decision FCTC/COP8(22); whereas parties to the WHO FCTC are urged to prioritise measures that protect people from exposure to their emissions and to explicitly extend smoke-free laws to include HTPs;

Added:N. whereas the current Council Recommendation (2009/C 296/02) sets out recommendations for the Member States, who are all parties to the WHO FCTC, to implement this framework convention, and thus provides guidance for them to comply with their legal commitments to protect people from second-hand smoke in all indoor workplaces, on public transport and in indoor public spaces;

Removed:M. whereas the regulation of HTPs and new and emerging nicotine and non-nicotine products remains fragmented across the EU, making it difficult for national authorities to enforce national legislation;

Added:O. whereas according to Principle 1 of the guidelines for the implementation of Article 8 of the WHO FCTC, effective measures to provide protection from exposure to tobacco smoke require the total elimination of smoking and tobacco smoke in specific spaces or environments in order to create a 100 % smoke-free environment;

Removed:N. whereas the Commission’s proposed revision of the Council Recommendation on smoke-free environments aims to better protect people, especially children, young people and pregnant women, from the effects of second-hand smoke and aerosols, and recommends extending smoke-free policies to key outdoor areas such as public playgrounds, amusement parks, swimming pools, healthcare and education facilities, public buildings and transport stations;

Added:P. whereas the Conference of the Parties (COP) to the WHO FCTC recognises HTPs as tobacco products and therefore as subject to the provisions of the WHO FCTC, as noted in Decision FCTC/COP8(22); whereas the COP8 concluded by urging the parties to the WHO FCTC to prioritise measures that protect people from exposure to HTP emissions and to explicitly extend smoke-free laws to include HTPs;

Removed:O. whereas the Commission’s proposal also recommends that Member States extend smoke-free environment policies to new and emerging products, such as HTPs and electronic cigarettes; whereas the proposal further recommends the exchange of best practices and the strengthening of international cooperation to maximise the impact of the measures taken across the EU;

Added:Q. whereas the regulation of HTPs and new and emerging nicotine and non-nicotine products remains fragmented across the EU, making it difficult for authorities to enforce national restrictions on the use of these products in the spaces or environments concerned;

Removed:P. whereas the Commission will provide support through a direct grant of EUR 16 million from the EU4Health programme, while EUR 80 million from the Horizon Europe programme has already been allocated to reinforce the control of tobacco, nicotine and related products, and addiction prevention; whereas the Commission will also develop a prevention toolkit to support the protection of children and young people’s health;

Added:R. whereas the proposed revision to the Council recommendation on smoke-free environments aims to better protect people, especially children, young people and pregnant women, from the effects of second-hand smoke and aerosols, and recommends extending smoke-free policies to key outdoor areas such as public playgrounds, amusement parks, swimming pools, healthcare and education premises, public buildings and transport stations;

Removed:Q. whereas the implementation of the recommendation should be monitored regularly to measure progress towards achieving their objectives and to identify gaps in the efforts to ensure smoke- and aerosol-free environments;

Added:S. whereas the Commission’s proposal was not preceded by a new impact assessment and the Commission is relying on the impact assessment conducted prior to the 2009 proposal for a Council recommendation;

Removed:R. whereas the practice of growing tobacco harms not only human health, but also soil health, endangering the future of our food supply; whereas today, a record 349 million people are facing acute food insecurity, while tobacco is being grown in over 124 countries, taking up 3.2 million hectares of fertile land that could be used to grow food;

Added:T. whereas the Commission’s proposal also recommends that Member States extend smoke-free environment policies to new and emerging products that emit smoke or aerosols, such as HTPs and e-cigarettes, and to exchange best practice and strengthen international cooperation to maximise the impact of the measures taken across the EU;

Removed:S. whereas ‘tobacco-free farms’, a joint initiative of the UN and the WHO, aims to support countries in creating an enabling and supportive crop production and marketing ecosystem to help farmers shift from tobacco growing to alternative livelihoods;

Added:U. whereas the Commission will provide support through a direct grant of EUR 16 million from the EU4Health programme, while EUR 80 million from the Horizon Europe programme have already been dedicated to reinforcing the control of tobacco, nicotine and related products, and addiction prevention; whereas the Commission will also develop a prevention toolkit to support the protection of children’s and young people’s health;

Removed:T. whereas tobacco control efforts are systematically opposed by the tobacco industry;

Added:V. whereas the implementation of the recommendation should be monitored regularly to measure progress towards achieving its objectives and to identify gaps in the efforts to extend smoke- and aerosol-free environments;

Removed:U. whereas, as a signatory to the WHO FCTC, the EU is obliged to limit its interactions with the tobacco industry and to make those interactions transparent;

Added:1. Reiterates its strong and continued support for the goal of creating a ‘tobacco-free generation’ by 2040, as set out in Europe’s Beating Cancer Plan; underlines the need to step up efforts to ensure that this aim is actually achieved;

Removed:V. whereas, in December 2023, the European Ombudsman found that the Commission had failed to ensure transparency across all its departments with regard to its meetings with tobacco lobbyists;

Added:2. Welcomes the Commission’s proposal for an updated Council recommendation on smoke- and aerosol-free environments; considers the rise in the use of HTPs, e-cigarettes and other aerosol-emitting products in public, outdoor and indoor spaces to be a risk to public health; considers that further assessment is needed, especially on the recommendation’s impact on the hotel and catering sector;

Removed:1. Deeply regrets the fact that the Commission delayed the publication of this long-awaited proposal by more than nine months after it was originally planned;

Added:3. Underlines that there are no proven safe levels of exposure to smoke and aerosols from tobacco and new and emerging products;

Removed:2. Reiterates its strong and continued support for the goal of creating a ‘tobacco-free generation’, as set out in Europe’s Beating Cancer Plan; underlines the need to step up efforts so that the aim of a ‘tobacco-free generation’ can be achieved by 2035, five years before the deadline; requests that appropriate resources be allocated to measure the progress and achievement of this goal;

Added:4. Underlines that smoke-free environments protect the health of both non-smokers and smokers, as they prevent non-smokers from exposure and encourage smokers to reduce their consumption or stop smoking completely;