Amendment 21 — part 1 to article 9, after paragraph 1: Amendment 21 — part 1 to article 9, after paragraph 1

Amendment 21 — part 1 to article 9, after paragraph 1

A9-0033/2023 - Ciarán Cuffe - Article 9, after § 1 - Am 21/1

Result not yet in the record

For: 272
Against: 340
Abstained: 16

roll-call vote at 12:25 · 43% of votes cast in favour

How the groups voted

A group’s line is the position at least two thirds of its voting MEPs took; otherwise it is shown as Divided. Groups from left to right.

Group	For	Against	Abstained	of	Line
The Left	3	11	0	14	Against
Greens	0	29	0	29	Against
S&D	50	6	0	56	For
Renew	2	36	0	38	Against
EPP	11	81	0	92	Against
ECR	25	0	3	28	For
Patriots	27	0	1	28	For
ESN	4	0	0	4	For
No group	3	1	0	4	—

“of” = MEPs of the group who voted. Groups as they are now.

Every MEP

628 MEPs voted. Open a group, or filter above.

The Left 14 MEPs

Anja Hazekamp Netherlands

Against

Damien Carême France

Against

Elena Kountoura Greece

Against

Giorgos Georgiou Cyprus

For voted against their group’s line

Konstantinos Arvanitis Greece

Against

Leila Chaibi France

Against

Luke Ming Flanagan Ireland

For voted against their group’s line

Manon Aubry France

Against

Marc Botenga Belgium

Against

Marina Mesure France

Against

Mario Furore Italy

For voted against their group’s line

Martin Schirdewan Germany

Against

Özlem Demirel Germany

Against

Younous Omarjee France

Against

Greens 29 MEPs

Alexandra Geese Germany

Against

Alice Kuhnke Sweden

Against

Ana Miranda Paz Spain

Against

Anna Cavazzini Germany

Against

Damian Boeselager Germany

Against

Daniel Freund Germany

Against

David Cormand France

Against

Diana Riba I Giner Spain

Against

Erik Marquardt Germany

Against

Hannah Neumann Germany

Against

Jutta Paulus Germany

Against

Katrin Langensiepen Germany

Against

Kim van Sparrentak Netherlands

Against

Kira Marie Peter-Hansen Denmark

Against

Markéta Gregorová Czechia

Against

Martin Häusling Germany

Against

Michael Bloss Germany

Against

Mounir Satouri France

Against

Nicolae Ștefănuță Romania

Against

Pär Holmgren Sweden

Against

Rasmus Andresen Germany

Against

Sara Matthieu Belgium

Against

Saskia Bricmont Belgium

Against

Sergey Lagodinsky Germany

Against

Terry Reintke Germany

Against

Thomas Waitz Austria

Against

Tilly Metz Luxembourg

Against

Tineke Strik Netherlands

Against

Ville Niinistö Finland

Against

S&D 56 MEPs

Alessandra Moretti Italy

For

Alex Agius Saliba Malta

For

Bernd Lange Germany

For

Biljana Borzan Croatia

For

Birgit Sippel Germany

For

Brando Benifei Italy

For

Camilla Laureti Italy

For

César Luena Spain

For

Christel Schaldemose Denmark

For

Costas Mavrides Cyprus

For

Cristina Maestre Spain

Against voted against their group’s line

Dan Nica Romania

For

Delara Burkhardt Germany

For

Dragoş Benea Romania

For

Evelyn Regner Austria

For

Evin Incir Sweden

For

Gabriele Bischoff Germany

For

Günther Sidl Austria

For

Hannes Heide Austria

For

Heléne Fritzon Sweden

For

Iratxe García Pérez Spain

For

Irene Tinagli Italy

For

Javi López Spain

For

Javier Moreno Sánchez Spain

For

Jens Geier Germany

For

Jonás Fernández Spain

For

Juan Fernando López Aguilar Spain

For

Kathleen van Brempt Belgium

Against voted against their group’s line

Klára Dobrev Hungary

For

Lara Wolters Netherlands

Against voted against their group’s line

Lina Gálvez Spain

For

Marc Angel Luxembourg

For

Marcos Ros Sempere Spain

For

Maria Grapini Romania

For

Maria Noichl Germany

For

Marianne Vind Denmark

For

Marina Kaljurand Estonia

For

Matjaž Nemec Slovenia

For

Matthias Ecke Germany

For

Mihai Tudose Romania

For

Mohammed Chahim Netherlands

Against voted against their group’s line

Nacho Sánchez Amor Spain

For

Nicolás González Casares Spain

For

Niels Fuglsang Denmark

For

Nils Ušakovs Latvia

For

Nora Mebarek France

Against voted against their group’s line

René Repasi Germany

For

Robert Biedroń Poland

For

Romana Jerković Croatia

For

Sven Mikser Estonia

For

Thijs Reuten Netherlands

Against voted against their group’s line

Tonino Picula Croatia

For

Tsvetelina Penkova Bulgaria

For

Udo Bullmann Germany

For

Victor Negrescu Romania

For

Vilija Blinkevičiūtė Lithuania

For

Renew 38 MEPs

Abir Al-Sahlani Sweden

Against

Andreas Glück Germany

Against

Asger Christensen Denmark

Against

Barry Andrews Ireland

Against

Bart Groothuis Netherlands

Against

Bernard Guetta France

Against

Billy Kelleher Ireland

Against

Charles Goerens Luxembourg

Against

Christophe Grudler France

Against

Elisabetta Gualmini Italy

For voted against their group’s line

Emma Wiesner Sweden

Against

Engin Eroglu Germany

Against

Eugen Tomac Romania

Against

Fabienne Keller France

Against

Gilles Boyer France

Against

Hilde Vautmans Belgium

Against

Ilhan Kyuchyuk Bulgaria

Against

Irena Joveva Slovenia

Against

Ivars Ijabs Latvia

Against

Jan-Christoph Oetjen Germany

Against

Jana Toom Estonia

Against

Jérémy Decerle France

Against

Karin Karlsbro Sweden

Against

Laurence Farreng France

Against

Malik Azmani Netherlands

Against

Martin Hojsík Slovakia

Against

Michal Wiezik Slovakia

Against

Moritz Körner Germany

Against

Nathalie Loiseau France

Against

Olivier Chastel Belgium

Against

Pascal Canfin France

Against

Petras Auštrevičius Lithuania

Against

Pina Picierno Italy

For voted against their group’s line

Sandro Gozi France

Against

Stéphanie Yon-Courtin France

Against

Svenja Hahn Germany

Against

Urmas Paet Estonia

Against

Valérie Hayer France

Against

EPP 92 MEPs

Adam Jarubas Poland

Against

Adrián Vázquez Lázara Spain

Against

Alexander Bernhuber Austria

Against

Andreas Schwab Germany

Against

Andrey Kovatchev Bulgaria

Against

Andrey Novakov Bulgaria

Against

Andrzej Halicki Poland

Against

Angelika Niebler Germany

Against

Angelika Winzig Austria

Against

Antonio López-Istúriz White Spain

Against

Arba Kokalari Sweden

Against

Axel Voss Germany

Against

Bartosz Arłukowicz Poland

Against

Caterina Chinnici Italy

For voted against their group’s line

Christian Doleschal Germany

Against

Christian Ehler Germany

Against

Dan-Ştefan Motreanu Romania

For voted against their group’s line

Daniel Buda Romania

Against

David Casa Malta

Against

David Mcallister Germany

Against

Dennis Radtke Germany

Against

Dolors Montserrat Spain

Against

Elissavet Vozemberg-Vrionidi Greece

Against

Elżbieta Katarzyna Łukacijewska Poland

Against

Emil Radev Bulgaria

Against

Emmanouil Kefalogiannis Greece

Against

Esteban González Pons Spain

Against

Ewa Kopacz Poland

Against

Francisco José Millán Mon Spain

Against

François-Xavier Bellamy France

Against

Fulvio Martusciello Italy

For voted against their group’s line

Gabriel Mato Spain

Against

Gheorghe Falcă Romania

Against

Herbert Dorfmann Italy

Against

Hildegard Bentele Germany

Against

Inese Vaidere Latvia

Against

Isabel Benjumea Benjumea Spain

Against

Isabel Wiseler-Lima Luxembourg

Against

Janusz Lewandowski Poland

Against

Javier Zarzalejos Spain

Against

Jens Gieseke Germany

Against

Jeroen Lenaers Netherlands

For voted against their group’s line

Jessica Polfjärd Sweden

Against

Jörgen Warborn Sweden

Against

Juan Ignacio Zoido Álvarez Spain

Against

Karlo Ressler Croatia

Against

Krzysztof Hetman Poland

Against

Lídia Pereira Portugal

Against

Liudas Mažylis Lithuania

Against

Loucas Fourlas Cyprus

Against

Luděk Niedermayer Czechia

Against

Lukas Mandl Austria

Against

Łukasz Kohut Poland

For voted against their group’s line

Magdalena Adamowicz Poland

Against

Manfred Weber Germany

Against

Manuela Ripa Germany

Against

Maria Walsh Ireland

Against

Marion Walsmann Germany

Against

Markus Ferber Germany

Against

Massimiliano Salini Italy

For voted against their group’s line

Michael Gahler Germany

For voted against their group’s line

Milan Zver Slovenia

Against

Mircea-Gheorghe Hava Romania

Against

Miriam Lexmann Slovakia

Against

Monika Hohlmeier Germany

Against

Nadine Morano France

Against

Niclas Herbst Germany

Against

Norbert Lins Germany

For voted against their group’s line

Pablo Arias Echeverría Spain

Against

Pascal Arimont Belgium

Against

Peter Liese Germany

Against

Pilar Del Castillo Vera Spain

Against

Radan Kanev Bulgaria

Against

Ralf Seekatz Germany

Against

Riho Terras Estonia

Against

Romana Tomc Slovenia

Against

Rosa Estaràs Ferragut Spain

Against

Sabine Verheyen Germany

For voted against their group’s line

Salvatore De Meo Italy

For voted against their group’s line

Sandra Kalniete Latvia

Against

Seán Kelly Ireland

Against

Siegfried Mureşan Romania

Against

Sirpa Pietikäinen Finland

Against

Stefan Berger Germany

Against

Sunčana Glavak Croatia

Against

Susana Solís Pérez Spain

Against

Sven Simon Germany

Against

Tomas Tobé Sweden

Against

Tomáš Zdechovský Czechia

For voted against their group’s line

Tomislav Sokol Croatia

Against

Vangelis Meimarakis Greece

Against

Željana Zovko Croatia

Against

ECR 28 MEPs

Adam Bielan Poland

For

Alexandr Vondra Czechia

For

Anna Zalewska Poland

For

Assita Kanko Belgium

Abstained voted against their group’s line

Beata Szydło Poland

For

Bert-Jan Ruissen Netherlands

For

Bogdan Rzońca Poland

For

Carlo Fidanza Italy

For

Charlie Weimers Sweden

For

Chiara Gemma Italy

For

Cristian Terheş Romania

For

Denis Nesci Italy

For

Dominik Tarczyński Poland

For

Elena Yoncheva Bulgaria

For

Emmanouil Fragkos Greece

Abstained voted against their group’s line

Giuseppe Milazzo Italy

For

Jaak Madison Estonia

For

Jadwiga Wiśniewska Poland

For

Joachim Stanisław Brudziński Poland

For

Johan van Overtveldt Belgium

Abstained voted against their group’s line

Kosma Złotowski Poland

For

Nicolas Bay France

For

Patryk Jaki Poland

For

Pietro Fiocchi Italy

For

Roberts Zīle Latvia

For

Sergio Berlato Italy

For

Veronika Vrecionová Czechia

For

Waldemar Tomaszewski Lithuania

For

Patriots 28 MEPs

André Rougé France

For

Catherine Griset France

For

Enikő Győri Hungary

For

Ernő Schaller-Baross Hungary

For

France Jamet France

For

Georg Mayer Austria

For

Gerolf Annemans Belgium

For

György Hölvényi Hungary

For

Harald Vilimsky Austria

For

Hermann Tertsch Spain

For

Isabella Tovaglieri Italy

For

Jordan Bardella France

For

Jorge Buxadé Villalba Spain

For

Kinga Gál Hungary

For

Margarita De La Pisa Carrión Spain

For

Marie Dauchy France

For

Mathilde Androuët France

For

Ondřej Knotek Czechia

Abstained voted against their group’s line

Paolo Borchia Italy

For

Philippe Olivier France

For

Raffaele Stancanelli Italy

For

Roman Haider Austria

For

Silvia Sardone Italy

For

Susanna Ceccardi Italy

For

Tamás Deutsch Hungary

For

Thierry Mariani France

For

Tom Vandendriessche Belgium

For

Virginie Joron France

For

ESN 4 MEPs

Christine Anderson Germany

For

Ivan David Czechia

For

Markus Buchheit Germany

For

Milan Uhrík Slovakia

For

No group 4 MEPs

Katarína Roth Neveďalová Slovakia

For

Kateřina Konečná Czechia

For

Martin Sonneborn Germany

Against

Monika Beňová Slovakia

For

Former MEPs 335 MEPs

Against

Abstained

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Abstained

Abstained

Against

For

Against

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

Against

For

Against

For

Against

Against

For

Against

For

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Abstained

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

For

Against

For

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

For

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Abstained

For

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Abstained

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

For

For

For

Abstained

Against

For

Against

For

Against

Abstained

For

Against

For

For

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

For

For

Against

Against

For

For

For

For

Against

For

Against

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

Abstained

Against

Against

For

For

Against

For

For

Against

For

For

For

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

For

Against

Against

For

For

For

Against

For

For

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Abstained

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Abstained

For

For

For

Against

For

For

For

Against

Against

Against

For

For

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

For

For

Against

For

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

For

For

Against

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

For

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

For

For

For

For

For

Against

For

For

For

For

For

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

For

For

Against

Against

For

Abstained

For

Against

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

Against

Against

For

Against

For

Against

For

“” = voted otherwise than a clear line (two thirds of its votes) of the group they sit in now. MEPs with no vote recorded are not listed.

Download CSV