Skip to content
EU Parl Watch

Every vote on this decision

Recommendation on smoke- and aerosol-free environments

50 votes in the order they were taken.Links open the , where every MEP’s position is recorded.

Before the final vote, MEPs decided on 12 amendments (4 adopted, 8 rejected) and 32 parts of the text voted on separately (15 adopted, 14 rejected, 3 lapsed).

· 12

  1. Vote 1:Amendment 13, adding text after paragraph 1

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – After § 1 – Am 13

    Rejected 241 for, 297 against, 25 abstained

    12:28

    Roll call requested by ECR

  2. Vote 2:Amendment 20, adding text after paragraph 1

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – After § 1 – Am 20

    Rejected 171 for, 396 against, 10 abstained

    12:28

    Roll call requested by Patriots

  3. Vote 4:Amendment 10 to paragraph 2

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 2 – Am 10

    Adopted 350 for, 222 against, 8 abstained

    12:28

    Roll call requested by EPP

  4. Vote 7:Amendment 15 to paragraph 4

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 4 – Am 15

    Adopted 289 for, 266 against, 19 abstained

    12:28

    Roll call requested by ECR

  5. Vote 8:Amendment 11, adding text after paragraph 4

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – After § 4 – Am 11

    Adopted 291 for, 259 against, 32 abstained

    12:29

    Roll call requested by EPP

  6. Vote 9:Amendment 16 to paragraph 5 — part 1

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 5 – Am 16/1

    Adopted 286 for, 280 against, 18 abstained

    12:29

    Roll call requested by ECR · split vote by EPP

    The part voted on

    ‘Regrets the fact that the Commission’s proposal does not clearly differentiate between the application of restrictions for traditional tobacco products and new and emerging products such as e-cigarettes, and does not apply a scientific evidence-based approach;’

  7. Vote 10:Amendment 16 to paragraph 5 — part 2

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 5 – Am 16/2

    Rejected 149 for, 403 against, 26 abstained

    12:29

    Roll call requested by ECR · split vote by EPP

    The part voted on

    ‘regrets that the lack of differentiation with regard to smoke-free environments gives the wrong signal, undermines the use of new and emerging products for those switching entirely away from cigarettes and perpetuates misconceptions about their relative risks, as the Commission was unable to support its proposal with conclusive scientific evidence regarding the impact of second-hand aerosols;’

  8. Vote 12:Amendment 17 to paragraph 6

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 6 – Am 17

    Rejected 253 for, 298 against, 23 abstained

    12:29

    Roll call requested by ECR

  9. Vote 13:Amendment 21 to paragraph 6

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 6 – Am 21

    Rejected 158 for, 403 against, 17 abstained

    12:30

    Roll call requested by Patriots

  10. Vote 17:Amendment 18 to paragraph 7

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 7 – Am 18

    Rejected 191 for, 369 against, 12 abstained

    12:30

    Roll call requested by ECR

  11. Vote 23:Amendment 19 to paragraph 12

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 12 – Am 19

    Rejected 268 for, 270 against, 35 abstained

    12:31

    Roll call requested by ECR

  12. Vote 31:Amendment 12, adding text after recital H

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – After recital H – Am 12

    Rejected 263 for, 277 against, 21 abstained

    12:33

    Roll call requested by ECR

· 32

32 votes on parts of the text: 15 adopted, 14 rejected, 3 lapsed or other

  1. Vote 3:Separate vote on paragraph 2

    Rejected show of hands

    Roll call requested by ECR

  2. Vote 5:Separate vote on paragraph 2

    Lapsed no count

    Roll call requested by ECR

  3. Vote 6:Separate vote on paragraph 2

    Lapsed no count

    Roll call requested by ECR

  4. Vote 11:Separate vote on paragraph 5

    Lapsed no count

    Roll call requested by EPP, ECR

  5. Vote 14:Paragraph 6 — part 1 of 2

    Rejected show of hands

    Split vote by EPP

    Text as a whole without the words: ‘restaurants and cafés’

  6. Vote 15:Paragraph 6 — part 1

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 6/1

    Adopted 368 for, 133 against, 64 abstained

    12:30

    Split vote by EPP

    Text as a whole without the words: ‘restaurants and cafés’

  7. Vote 16:Paragraph 6 — part 2

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 6/2

    Rejected 194 for, 348 against, 31 abstained

    12:30

    Roll call requested by EPP · split vote by EPP

    those words

  8. Vote 18:Separate vote on paragraph 8

    Adopted 346 for, 206 against, 13 abstained

  9. Vote 19:Vote on text inserted after paragraph 10

    Rejected show of hands

  10. Vote 20:Vote on text inserted after paragraph 10

    Rejected show of hands

  11. Vote 21:Separate vote on paragraph 11

    Rejected show of hands

  12. Vote 22:Vote on text inserted after paragraph 11

    Rejected show of hands

  13. Vote 24:Recital C — part 1 of 2

    Adopted show of hands

    Split vote by ECR

    The part voted on

    ‘whereas the market for and use of new and emerging tobacco, nicotine and non-nicotine products, such as electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes), heated tobacco products (HTPs) and other aerosol-emitting devices, are rapidly growing’

  14. Vote 25:Recital C — part 2 of 2

    Adopted show of hands

    Split vote by ECR

    ‘and are a concern from a public health perspective;’

  15. Vote 26:Vote on text inserted after recital C

    Rejected show of hands

  16. Vote 27:Recital D — part 1 of 2

    Adopted show of hands

    Split vote by ECR

    The part voted on

    ‘whereas second-hand smoke causes premature deaths and increases the risk of contracting a wide range of NCDs, including cancer, cardiovascular diseases and chronic respiratory diseases;’

  17. Vote 28:Recital D — part 2 of 2

    Adopted show of hands

    Split vote by ECR

    The part voted on

    ‘whereas second-hand aerosols from new and emerging products emit fine and ultra-fine particles, posing a health risk not only to the user but also to bystanders;’

  18. Vote 29:Vote on text inserted after recital D

    Rejected show of hands

  19. Vote 30:Separate vote on recital E

    Adopted 337 for, 216 against, 5 abstained

    Separate vote by ECR

  20. Vote 32:Separate vote on recital M

    Rejected show of hands

  21. Vote 33:Separate vote on recital P

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – Recital P

    Adopted 407 for, 110 against, 51 abstained

    12:33

    Roll call requested by ECR

  22. Vote 34:Separate vote on recital Q

    Adopted show of hands

    Separate vote by ECR

  23. Vote 35:Separate vote on recital R

    Adopted show of hands

    Split vote by ECR

  24. Vote 36:Recital R — part 2

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – Recital R/2

    Adopted 409 for, 142 against, 16 abstained

    12:34

    Roll call requested by ECR · split vote by ECR

    those words

  25. Vote 37:Separate vote on recital T

    Adopted show of hands

  26. Vote 38:Recital V — part 1 of 2

    Adopted show of hands

    Split vote by ECR

    Text as a whole without the words: ‘and aerosol-’

  27. Vote 39:Recital V — part 2 of 2

    Adopted show of hands

    Split vote by ECR

    those words

  28. Vote 42:Paragraph 2 — part 1

    B10-0174/2024 – § 2/1

    Adopted 222 for, 204 against, 23 abstained

    12:35

    Roll call requested by ECR

  29. Vote 43:Paragraph 2 — part 2

    B10-0174/2024 – § 2/2

    Rejected 184 for, 245 against, 50 abstained

    12:35

    Roll call requested by ECR

  30. Vote 44:Separate vote on paragraph 5

    Rejected show of hands

    Roll call requested by EPP, ECR

  31. Vote 45:Paragraph 6 — part 2 of 2

    Rejected show of hands

    Roll call requested by EPP · split vote by EPP

    those words

  32. Vote 46:Separate vote on paragraph 14

    Rejected show of hands

· 2

  1. Vote 40:Final vote — text as a whole · the decisive vote

    RC-B10-0173/2024 – Motion for a resolution (as a whole)

    Rejected 152 for, 378 against, 26 abstained

    12:34

    Roll call requested by EPP

  2. Vote 47:Final vote — text as a whole

    Motion for a resolution (as a whole)

    Rejected 150 for, 342 against, 14 abstained

    Roll call requested by EPP

Other votes · 4

  1. Vote 41:B10-0173/2024

    Rejected show of hands

  2. Vote 48:B10-0175/2024

    Rejected show of hands

  3. Vote 49:B10-0176/2024

    Rejected show of hands

  4. Vote 50:B10-0177/2024

    Rejected show of hands

← Back to the decision